

What Evanston Homeowners Should Know Before Installing a Tankless Water Heater
If you’re an Evanston homeowner thinking about making the switch to a tankless water heater, the short answer is yes — they’re worth it for the right home. But “the right home” is the key phrase here. A tankless unit is not a drop-in swap for your old 50-gallon tank. There are real infrastructure questions that need honest answers before anyone cuts a pipe or runs a new gas line. Here’s what you need to know upfront so you don’t get blindsided on installation day.
Tankless water heaters heat water on demand instead of keeping a full tank hot 24 hours a day. That means lower energy bills, no running out of hot water mid-shower, and a unit that can last 20 years with proper maintenance. In older North Shore homes — the kind you see throughout Evanston, Wilmette, and Highland Park — where mechanical rooms are tight and square footage is valuable, getting rid of a bulky tank is a real practical benefit too.
But here’s what the manufacturers’ brochures gloss over: most homes weren’t built with a tankless unit in mind. A gas-fired tankless water heater demands significantly higher BTU input than a traditional tank — we’re talking 150,000 to 200,000 BTUs or more on a whole-house unit. Your existing half-inch gas line almost certainly can’t carry that load. Upgrading to three-quarter inch or larger gas supply is a common part of the job, and in some older Evanston homes, it means tracing line back further than you’d expect.
This is the piece that national franchise plumbers and generic how-to content consistently underplay. You’ll find plenty of articles that say “a tankless water heater requires a dedicated gas line” and stop there. That’s technically true but not very useful. What you actually need to know is this:
A licensed plumber should do a gas load calculation before quoting the job. If someone gives you a price over the phone without asking these questions, that’s a red flag.
Gas tankless units require dedicated PVC or stainless steel venting — they cannot use your old water heater’s flue. Direct-vent models pull combustion air from outside and exhaust directly through an exterior wall, which is actually a more reliable setup in Chicagoland’s cold winters. The installation requires drilling through your exterior wall, fitting proper termination caps, and making sure the vent location meets code clearance requirements from windows, doors, and gas meters.
In a historic or older Evanston home with brick or stone construction, that exterior penetration takes more time and the right tools. It’s not difficult for an experienced crew, but it’s not something to rush or guess on — a poorly terminated vent is a carbon monoxide hazard. This is non-negotiable work that needs to be done right.
Tankless water heaters are rated by flow rate in gallons per minute (GPM). In a cold climate like Chicagoland, incoming groundwater temperatures drop significantly in winter — sometimes to 38°F or below. That matters because the unit has to work harder to raise cold water to your target temperature. A unit that performs adequately in mild climates may struggle to keep up with simultaneous demand — a shower running while someone’s doing dishes — when the incoming water is that cold.
For most Evanston homes running two to three bathrooms with a kitchen, you’re typically looking at a unit rated for at least 9–10 GPM. For larger homes closer to the Northbrook or Highland Park end of the North Shore corridor, that number climbs. Don’t let a plumber spec you a unit based only on the number of bathrooms without discussing your actual simultaneous usage patterns and local groundwater temperature.
You can learn more about the options available and what’s right for your household on our tankless water heater services page.
In Cook County and most North Shore municipalities — including Evanston — a water heater replacement requires a permit and inspection. This is true even if you’re swapping tank for tank, and it’s especially true for a tankless conversion that involves new gas line work and a new penetration through the building envelope. Some larger national franchise plumbers will pull permits correctly. Others will not, or will leave you to figure it out yourself. Either way, if unpermitted work is discovered during a home sale or insurance claim, you’re the one holding the problem.
Ask your plumber directly: Do you pull the permit, or do I? A legitimate local plumber handles permits as part of the job and knows the inspectors in the municipality where the work is happening.
A full tankless water heater installation — including gas line upgrade, venting, and the unit itself — is a meaningful investment. If you’re doing it right on an older Evanston home, you should budget accordingly. Excel Plumbing offers 0% interest special financing on larger jobs like this, so you’re not forced to cut corners on the install to fit a tighter cash budget. Ask about it when you call.
If you’re also dealing with aging residential plumbing elsewhere in the house — galvanized supply lines, old shutoff valves, a water heater that sat too long and caused corrosion — it’s often smart to evaluate the bigger picture while you have a plumber on site.
Most installations take one full day. If significant gas line work or additional permits are required, budget for two days. Don’t let anyone rush this job.
Technically an ambitious DIYer can attempt it, but gas line work requires a licensed plumber in Illinois. Permit requirements apply regardless. Mistakes on gas connections or venting are serious safety hazards. This is not a weekend project.
Yes, but sizing matters more here than in warmer climates because of cold incoming groundwater. Make sure your unit is properly spec’d for Chicagoland conditions — not just rated for a “large home” in a generic sense.
Annual descaling is the big one. Chicagoland municipal water has moderate to high mineral content depending on the suburb, and calcium buildup inside the heat exchanger reduces efficiency over time. Annual flushing keeps the unit running at spec and extends its lifespan considerably.
For most households, yes — especially when no one’s drawing hot water, you’re not heating a full tank around the clock. But if you have a large household with near-constant hot water demand, the efficiency gap narrows. A licensed plumber can help you model the comparison honestly based on your actual usage.
If you’re in Evanston, Glenview, Wilmette, or anywhere across the North Shore and you’re seriously considering a tankless water heater, we’ll give you a straight answer about what your home actually needs — not a sales pitch for the most expensive unit on the shelf. Excel Plumbing is based in Wheeling and has been serving Chicagoland homeowners and businesses since 2002. Flat-rate pricing, licensed work, permits handled correctly.
Contact Excel Plumbing to schedule a consultation or request a quote. We’ll assess your existing setup and tell you exactly what a proper tankless installation involves for your specific home — before any work starts.
Rated 4.8 out of 5 from 757 customer reviews.
We highly recommend Luke.He is awesome! His job is top-notch – super professional, honest, and he does really good work. His suggestions are spot-on, and he makes sure everything's fixed before he leaves. We're super happy with his plumbing skills, plus he's really polite. Thumbs up for Luke! 🌟
Yuri was very knowledgeable and efficient ! I had a bidet toilet installed and it went seamlessly! high recommend excel plumbing
David was very professional, and did and amazing job for us. Highly recommend.
Yury and his partner did a great job trying to target the problem and come up with solutions.
We had 2 back-to-back plumbing issues this month. Denny was so great the first visit, I requested him by name for the second visit. We couldn't be more happy with his work, the price, or the overall kindness and service from Mike, Kelly, and everyone at Excel Plumbing. I highly recommend them.
Ed did a great job in diagnosing the issue and fixing it by installing a new kitchen faucet. He was professional and friendly.
Very pleased with this company. They are polite, professional and reasonably priced. I will definitely be using them again for any unfortunate plumbing issues.
We recently moved in to our new apartment and had an issue with the sink in the kitchen. I called excel plumbing and the service man showed up very fast and stated working on the problem immediately. After the issue was fixed, he went into the detail to explain to me what parts were changed and how to avoid having the same issue in the future. The price was good and the service was excellent! Thank you!