
Water heater quotes vary more than people expect, and the spread is rarely the heater. It is what has to change around it. A straight swap of the same type in an accessible basement is the cheapest job there is. The same heater, moved, converted to another fuel, or brought up to current code, is a different number entirely.
We would rather explain what drives the figure than publish a headline price that turns out not to apply to your house. Below is what actually moves it, and how the running costs compare — because the cheapest unit to install is frequently not the cheapest to own.
Excel Plumbing quotes flat rate, in writing, after seeing the installation. No hourly meter while we work out what is needed.
For the options themselves see gas, electric, tankless and hybrid heat pump units, or replacement for what an install involves.
Like-for-like or not. Same fuel, same format, same location, existing connections usable — that is the baseline. Everything else is more.
Fuel conversion. Gas to electric needs a new 240-volt circuit and spare panel capacity. Electric to gas needs gas supply and venting. Either can add a substantial amount, and occasionally the panel or the gas line turns out to be the deciding factor rather than the heater.
Tank to tankless. Usually a larger gas line and dedicated venting. On a retrofit this is often the largest single line on the quote.
Code catch-up. If the existing install predates current requirements, replacement is when they apply. Expansion tank, correct relief discharge, drip pan, proper venting, dielectric unions. These are not padding — they are what the inspection checks.
Access. A basement you can walk into with a trolley is straightforward. A crawlspace, a tight attic, a third-floor condo, or a unit behind a finished wall is not.
Permit. Most villages require one for a water heater. It is a real cost and it is on the quote.
A water heater is typically among the largest energy users in a home after heating and cooling, and it runs every day for a decade or more. Ordered from cheapest to most expensive to run, for a typical household here:
Hybrid heat pump is the cheapest by a clear margin, because it moves heat instead of making it — commonly around a third of the consumption of standard electric. Gas is next, because gas costs less per unit of heat delivered than electricity in Illinois. Tankless gas is a little better than tank gas, since there are no standby losses, though the saving is smaller than most people expect for a household that uses hot water steadily. Standard electric is the most expensive to run.
That ordering is why the cheapest unit to install is so often not the cheapest to own. A standard electric tank is inexpensive to fit and then quietly costs you the difference back every month for twelve years.
Hybrid heat pump units frequently attract utility rebates and federal efficiency credits, and these can be large enough to close the gap with a standard tank outright. High-efficiency gas units sometimes qualify too. Programmes and amounts change, so confirm what is current when you buy rather than relying on last year’s figure — your utility’s own programme page is the authority.
Under about eight years with a failed part, repair. Over about twelve with a corroded tank, replace. In between, weigh the repair against the remaining life, and remember that a tank leaking from its body is not repairable at any price. We will quote both where both are genuinely options and tell you which we would choose.

Cannot be combined with other offers. Restrictions apply, please inquire.

Cannot be combined with other offers. Restrictions apply, please inquire.

Cannot be combined with other offers. Restrictions apply, please inquire.

Cannot be combined with other offers. Restrictions apply, please inquire.

Cannot be combined with other offers. Restrictions apply, please inquire.
Read our reviews on BBB·Yelp·Google·Angi·HomeAdvisor
Available for Water Heaters, Sump Pumps, Drain & Sewers,
Excavation and other plumbing jobs








